The bad boy who lands on the naughty list must endure the coal. However, the most compelling stories are those where the bad boy earns his way off the naughty list through genuine reform.
Spray-painting a historic monument. Naughty Behavior: Peer-pressured destruction. Punishment: 200 hours of monument restoration, written apology, curfew. Outcome: Successful reformation. The punishment fit the crime, and the bad boy became an advocate for preservation.